Films Before Books

Have you ever noticed how people are always going on and on about how you should read the book before you see the movie for some nonexistent reason, like the protagonist’s boyfriend’s third cousin had a different name in the book?

Well, I find this practise completely fallacious.

You see, whenever you read the book before the movie, the movie always seems craptastical in comparison–but when you read the book after you see the movie, both the movie and the book turn out to be not that bad!…Unless you’re talking about the Eragon film, which is crappy no matter when you watch it.

I only bring this up because I watched Brief Interviews with Hideous Men last night and I thought to myself: “This is super awesome! It’s a film editor’s dream!”…And then I looked it up on Rotten Tomatoes and the consensus was, and I quote:  “…John Krasinski’s adaptation of David Foster Wallace’s Brief Interviews with Hideous Men…doesn’t match the depth of the book.”

This got me to thinking: How do you compare a film with a book? In a book, you don’t have to worry about camera angles or art direction. Similarly, in a film you don’t have to worry about detailed description. Trying to compare the film version of a book with the book itself is like trying to compare a flash drive with a painting of flash drive. It doesn’t work, and it never will.

So, here’s to illogical systems of judging films, may they be shot in the back of the neck!

Now, you all can complain about how David Foster Wallace’s collection of short stories kicked the crap out of the movie,but not me. No, I’m just going to watch the awesome montages.

~~La Stranezza

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Films Before Books

  1. HOORAY!!! ERAGON [the movie] STINKS!!! I like the books, though. I completely agree with you on that comparison between books and their movies. The only movies I ever saw that were even close to the books were Lord of the Rings, Fail-Safe, and Star Wars (since the books were made from the movies).

  2. Ahem. I liked the Eragon movie. My problem with watching movies without reading the books first makes me bored of the book before I’ve even read it (which explains why I can’t get past the twentieth page of Eragon).

Say Anything

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s